The outlook is gloomy for investors hanging on for the next QE.
Investors are starting to realise that Sunday’s Greek election result was about the worst outcome they could have ended up with.
If Greece had out-and-out rejected austerity, we’d have had some panic – but we might have had some progress too.
Faced with plunging markets and the threat of an imminent Greek exit, central bankers around the world would have had their fingers poised over the ‘print’ button. Perhaps the Europeans might even have felt a bit of pressure to make something resembling a concrete decision.
As it stands, Greece’s indecision has left markets in limbo. Things aren’t great, but the threat of a Lehman moment has passed. That means central bankers just can’t justify another spending spree.
Federal Reserve chief Ben Bernanke still tried to toss investors a bone. But the market sulkily spat it right back at him…
The Fed hasn’t pressed the emergency button – yet.
Operation Twist – in Place of QE3
Instead of printing more money – QE3 – the Federal Reserve has opted to extend ‘Operation Twist’, which was originally meant to finish at the end of this month.
‘Twist’ involves the Fed trying to keep longer-term interest rates down; it does this by selling short-term debt and using the funds to buy US Treasuries with maturities of six to 30 years.
So “Twisting” doesn’t add more money to the system, it just takes it out of one end and puts it in at another. Trying to suppress interest rates over a longer period should ‘help to make broader financial conditions more accommodative,’ as the Fed puts it – but it doesn’t provide the caffeine jolt of fresh new money that the markets clearly crave.
Investors probably shouldn’t have been as surprised as they were – the fact is, things just aren’t that bad yet.
We seem to have forgotten that quantitative easing (QE) was at one point a potentially deadly monetary experiment – a desperate measure designed to prevent the complete collapse of civil society. Now every time the S&P 500 looks like losing a few points, or a bit of bad economic data comes out, it’s a case of ‘let’s just whack a little more plutonium in the fuel tank’.
The US is certainly slowing down, there’s no doubt about that. Fed officials cut their growth estimates for the US quite sharply: they reckon it will grow at between 1.9% and 2.4% this year, rather than 2.4% to 2.9%. And there are plenty of smart people who think that the US is already in recession and has been for a long time (although this uses a broader definition of recession than the usual ‘two shrinking quarters in a row’ notion).
However, while growth concerns are real, the Fed needs a more concrete panic phase to launch anything as drastic as QE3 – a more rebellious Greek vote, sparking a rush for liquidity and a sharp market plunge, might have done it. As it is, investors have gone from fearing the end of the world last week to being paralysed with indecision.
They’re too afraid to buy in case something nasty happens. And they’re too afraid to be out of the market because if something nasty happens, they think that policymakers will flood the world with money.
With No Sign of QE3 Investors Are Right To Be Nervous
As far as I can see, investors are right to feel indecisive. It’s possible that the US economy doesn’t “need” QE3, but Ben Bernanke will take any excuse he can get to err on the side of caution.
And he’ll probably get that excuse later in the year. The economy is slowing down right across the globe, not just in Europe and the US: China saw manufacturing sector activity shrink for the eighth month in a row in June.
As a result, life is getting tougher for companies. The latest company to warn on profits is US consumer goods giant Procter & Gamble. Some of its woes are self-inflicted, but the wider picture is pretty grim too.
As James Mackintosh notes in his FT column, operating profits globally are ‘now falling at an annual rate of 5%’. That’s similar to the sort of fall seen at the start of recessions in the 1990s and the 2000s.
Combine all this with the potential for an ongoing, rolling panic in Europe, and Ben is bound to come up with a reason to provide more QE.
John Stepek
Contributing Editor, Money Morning
Publisher’s Note: This article originally appeared in MoneyWeek (UK)
From the Archives…
The Problem With the Spanish Bailout
2012-06-15 – Keith Fitz-Gerald
Australian Housing – How to Avoid This Pauper’s Retirement Trap
2012-06-14 – Kris Sayce
Why Warren Buffett is Loading Up on Tungsten
2012-06-13 – Don Miller
China’s Economic Data Statistics: Just Add Salt
2012-06-12 – Dr. Alex Cowie
Why Graphite is One of the Few Places For Savvy Investors to Make Money
2012-06-11 – Dr. Alex Cowie
