One of the big stories of 2012 so far has been China’s slowdown.
Up until this year, China bulls argued that growth would never slow below 8% a year, because the party wouldn’t let it.
Yet the growth target was officially lowered to 7.5% earlier this year, as it became clear the Chinese economy was slowing. And with demand weak across the globe and the Chinese banking system carrying huge bad debts, it could get far worse.
So you might be inclined to feel a bit sorry for Xi Jinping. He’s the new leader of the Chinese Communist Party. He takes over from the previous president, Hu Jintao, just as the Chinese economy faces perhaps its biggest challenges yet.
The bad news is that what China really needs is some radical reform. Unfortunately, it’s not likely to get it under Xi. And that could be grim for the global economy too.
Why China’s Economy Needs Change
Economic reforms in 1979 kicked off China’s boom as the country was able to use its vast supply of cheap labour to grow rapidly. But in recent years, rising wages and soaring transport costs have reduced its cost advantage. Meanwhile, the large numbers of state-run firms are unable to compete with Western rivals on quality.
What’s the solution? More reform would help. A World Bank report suggested earlier this year that the state should stop directly running companies. Over time, subsidies should be reduced, and some firms sold off. Given that the report was prepared with the help of a major Chinese think tank, it looked as though this change might be endorsed.
And some of the most conservative politicians have fallen out of favour. Bo Xilai, who wanted a return to the Mao era, saw his career implode over corruption allegations.
There have even been rumours that the Chinese leadership was planning for China to move much closer to Singapore’s political and economic system. While the Communist Party would still retain power through indirect controls, the hope was that greater openness would cut corruption, while private enterprise would be encouraged.
Why Change Isn’t Coming Anytime Soon to the Chinese Economy
However, these hopes may have been premature. Outgoing leader Hu will still have a large amount of influence, even after the transition is complete in March. So it matters that Hu, in his last speech, put the emphasis on stability, not reform: ‘We must unswervingly follow the path of socialism with Chinese characteristics’. He even suggested that control over the press should be increased.
‘The Party leaders have decided that China’s political system will remain Communist, centralised, disciplined from the top-down and un-Western,’ says John McCreary of KGS Nightwatch. Anyone expecting reform has ‘misread badly the Communist leadership’.
For one thing, Xi played a key role in shaping China’s response to the financial crisis. That involved printing money to spend on infrastructure and subsidies for state firms. So Xi is hardly a big fan of the market economy.
He won’t have a free hand in any case. He will have to get agreement from the Politburo Standing Committee for most major decisions. The most influential of these leaders are opposed to radical change, or have vested interests in keeping the state at the heart of the Chinese economy.
Why What Happens in China Matters to You
China is the second-biggest economy in the world. With the developed world still fragile, many people are pinning their hopes on China to drive growth in future.
But reform is needed if China is to move towards being a consumer-led economy. It can’t keep relying on pumping money into infrastructure, or selling cheap goods overseas. That model is exhausted.
Yet its new leaders don’t look likely to deliver China the kind of change that it needs. That increases the chances of an outright crash. And even if it doesn’t, growth could continue to be disappointing.
A slower-growing Chinese economy will need fewer raw materials. This is bad news for industrial metals producers and commodity intensive countries such as Australia.
Contributing Writer, Money Morning
Publisher’s Note: This is an edited version of an article that originally appeared in MoneyWeek
From the Archives…
Retirees and the Fed Face Off
16-11-2012 – Kris Sayce
Attention Investors: This Market is Worse Than it Looks
15-11-2012 – Kris Sayce
Avoid the Slaughter: Watch This Key Stock Market Pointer
14-11-2012 – Murray Dawes
Why Lithium is Another ‘Rare’ Element on China’s Radar
13-11-2012 – Dr. Alex Cowie
Who Says Gold Doesn’t Pay ‘Interest’?
12-11-2012 – Dr. Alex Cowie
Already a subscriber to Money Morning... or simply, just like what you're reading? Then show your support and spread the word...