- Money Morning Australia

Two Reasons to Steer Clear of the Chinese Stock Market

Written on 21 November 2012 by Merryn Somerset-Webb

Two Reasons to Steer Clear of the Chinese Stock Market

Here are some things that we know. We know that long-term stock market returns are utterly unrelated to economic growth; instead, they are related to the price at which you buy your stake.

Buy a market when it is cheap, and history tells us you will make good long term returns; buy a market when it is expensive, and history tells us you will not.

We also know that when a market is cheap, sentiment will be such that everyone will have a reason why it will stay cheap forever, and must be avoided at all cost. The clever investor is the one who ignores the noise and looks at the price.

Beware the Bear Market Trap

This brings me to the Chinese stock market – people keep telling me how cheap it is. Brian Dennehy of fundexpert.co.uk sent me a chart this week showing how the major markets have performed since October 2007. The S&P 500 is down 10% and the FTSE 100 is down about 11%.

But the Shanghai Composite index is down a nasty 62%. The Chinese stock market doesn’t look that good over a 20-year period either: the MSCI China Index started at 100 on December 31 1992; it is now at 59.

It is a story borne out if you look at short-term fund performance too. The best performers in the US stock market are up between 18 and 20% over the past year, while even the very best performer in the Chinese stock market – First State Greater China Growth – is up only just over 4%. Its runner-up, Baillie Gifford Greater China, is down 2%.

Dennehy points out that the Chinese stock market bears many of the hallmarks of a bear market hitting bottom. There is a consensus growing against it among foreigners – note Barron’s ‘Falling Star’ cover from July this year, explaining why low Chinese growth is bad news for stocks – and among locals.

The number of new trading accounts being opened has fallen to 2008 levels, and trading volumes on both main markets (Shanghai and Shenzhen) dropped by 30% in the first half of this year.

Next up is the fact that its price/earnings ratio, “depending on who you believe”, is either at or near a record low, somewhere between ten and 12 times and much where it was in 1995. Chinese stocks used to trade at a massive premium to those in the rest of Asia; now they trade on a discount.

Dennehy isn’t alone in his enthusiasm. The idea that Chinese equities are historically cheap is gaining momentum: even Asia-based stock guru and über bear Marc Faber told me a few weeks ago that at these prices, China is due a major bounce.

Given that I am usually keen to push you into cheap equities (it is the only way to survive this kind of very low interest rate environment) you might now expect me to suggest that you start buying shares. But while I wouldn’t be at all surprised to see China’s stock market rally nicely from these levels, it just doesn’t make sense as a long-term hold. Why? Two reasons.

Why You Should Avoid the Chinese Stock Market

First, it isn’t cheap enough. Very few valuation methods have ever shown themselves to be of any use in predicting where stock markets might go. The cyclically adjusted p/e ratio (Cape), however, does. And on Cape, China still looks expensive: cheap would be under 11 times, and China is on more like 16 times.

But the real argument against anyone but stock traders investing in the Chinese stock market isn’t really anything to do with the current price or with the various theories about how equities should or could be valued, or about the noise surrounding the political changes and economic slowdown.

Instead, as CLSA’s Russell Napier pointed out to me this week, it is about something more fundamental – the usual measures don’t hold good because the things listed on Chinese stock exchanges aren’t proper equities.

An equity is a real share in an asset that you hope represents growth in the productive part of an economy – and a share that entitles you to all the rights that come with owning that asset.

But if you buy into a market such as China’s where the vast majority of shares are state-owned (about 80% of the market), that is not really what you are getting.

As one long-term China bear noted this week, ‘what is a Chinese bank but a branch of the Ministry of Finance which makes non-performing loans to state-owned companies, some of which are funded with equity sold to foreigners?’ Quite.

Own Chinese stocks and you just don’t have the same kind of effective ownership as the word ‘equity’ suggests you should, something that surely makes most of our theories on valuation more or less irrelevant.

It is also worth noting that state control matters more than usual at the moment. Why? Inequality, the corruption that causes inequality, and the new focus on both in China.

In the West, if governments want corporates to distribute more of their profits to labour (which they surely do) they have to beg, legislate or take the money in taxes and redistribute it themselves.

In China, the government (old and probably new too) can work to smooth things a little with a firm endorsement of fast-rising wages, something it can directly deliver via its ownership of the corporate sector regardless of whether the small pool of private shareholders agree with the policy or not.

That – obviously – suggests a state-sponsored squeeze on profit margins, says Napier. The other obvious risk to bear in mind is that the Chinese government probably doesn’t want to own most of the market forever, so we can surely expect it to sell parts of the various stakes it holds whenever prices rise.

As I’ve written before, in turbulent times you need to invest as far away from anything controlled by government as you can. Stocks owned by the state and listed in a command economy are too close to government for comfort.

Merryn Somerset Webb
Contributing Editor, Money Morning

Publisher’s Note: This article originally appeared in MoneyWeek

From the Archives…

Retirees and the Fed Face Off
16-11-2012 – Kris Sayce

Attention Investors: This Market is Worse Than it Looks
15-11-2012 – Kris Sayce

Avoid the Slaughter: Watch This Key Stock Market Pointer
14-11-2012 – Murray Dawes

Why Lithium is Another ‘Rare’ Element on China’s Radar
13-11-2012 – Dr. Alex Cowie

Who Says Gold Doesn’t Pay ‘Interest’?
12-11-2012 – Dr. Alex Cowie

Already a subscriber to Money Morning... or simply, just like what you're reading? Then show your support and spread the word...
Share this post on...

Leave a Comment

Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.

If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to moneymorning@moneymorning.com.au

Comments are closed.

FREE INVESTMENT REPORT: The Top 5 Oversold Blue-Chip Stocks in Australia

These five Aussie stocks all have something very powerful in common…and it could see them bounce up in the coming weeks and months. For all the details download this report right now.

PLUS you'll get Money Morning every weekday...absolutely free.

Enter your email address below and hit the 'Claim My Free Report' button now.

Privacy Statement
We will collect and handle your personal information in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
You can cancel your subscription at any time

Diggers and Drillers

A 3-Point Plan to Re-Engage with the Aussie Mining Boom

This new video reveals a way for Aussie share investors like you to RE-ENGAGE with the next phase of the mining boom…while valuations are still dirt-cheap…

The plan centres round three specific stocks.

To find out what they are, click here.

Australian Small-Cap Investigator

The Australian wildcatter
exploring oil's 'final frontier'

The US Geological Survey says this area contains up to 71 billion barrels of oil.

Only a few explorers have secured licences to drill.

One of them is a daring little Aussie firm that begins drilling 'in early 2014'.

According to small-cap analysts Tim Dohrmann it's impossible to speculate just how high this one could go. Find out why here.

World War D

Couldn’t make it to our
‘War Summit’?

Don’t sweat it. Click here for the next best thing…

World War D was the most important meeting of minds of the decade so far. What came out of it will almost certainly force you to reshape your investment plan for the rest of the decade. There's no way to go back in time and get inside the Savoy Ballroom of the Grand Hyatt.

But you can do the next best thing…
to find out what it is, click here.

  • ^NDX3557.036-31.769 - -0.89%
  • ^FTSE6674.74-7.02 - -0.11%
  • ^AORD5520.500+18.300 - +0.33%
  • ^AXJO5536.400+18.600 - +0.34%
  • AUDUSD=X0.9293
  • USDJPY=X102.525

Graphic Ad 1 – Blue Chip Stocks Report

Revolutionary Tech Investor

This report is about TECH MOON-SHOTS

Four of them, to be precise.

It's an early-days project. But one biotech aiming for the cancer moon-shot is already up - get this - 497.14% since tipped.

For four more tech moon-shots, click here.

Gowdie Family Wealth

The worst mistake you can make when handing wealth on to your kids

This brand new investor briefing shows you what your family’s in for if you don’t take care to leave your wealth to them in exactly the right way.

And it shows you precisely how to prevent infighting, recklessness and misunderstanding over money.

Read it here.

The Money For Life Letter

Holden. Toyota. Qantas. BUST

Do you really expect the share market to boom in times like these? That's why Nick Hubble says the best thing you can do right now is invest for safety and income.

This brand new video shows you how you can get predictable, reliable and rock solid cash flow no matter what happens in the wider economy.

You could lock in up to $20,000 a year - and that's just the start. See how here.

Sound Money. Sound Investments. [bullish prediction]

Greg Canavan's first bullish prediction in four years

Greg Canavan
doesn't make forecasts like this often.

When he does, it's because he’s found something that could make you money for years to come.

Read more here.

Is the Australian Housing Boom Really Back?

The Denning Report

2014 Predicted

Dan Denning accurately forecast 2013's flight from
bonds to stocks, the commodities crash and the
Aussie dollar top…to the exact week

In this brand new forecast report, he shares his
three critical predictions for 2014…

More Recommended Reading Below...

The Pursuit of Happiness & The Daily Reckoning

  • The Pursuit of Happiness
  • The Daily Reckoning Australia

Two days from now Australia will get a taste for what happens in American sports stadiums every day [Read More...]

Would you approve this chemical? Would you allow this to come to market? Table salt would simply not [Read More...]

If these lessons can be passed onto the next generation, what a world it would be. Healthier, genuin [Read More...]

3D printing is changing medicine, consumer products, art and manufacturing. The impact it’s having o [Read More...]

Done properly, a retirement business can not only help fill a retiree’s time and replace their work [Read More...]

It was necessary just to stay in the same place. Take it away, the US stock market crashes...and the [Read More...]

The end of Australia’s recession-less run is waiting somewhere. Even the US is due for another reces [Read More...]

You can see the property cycle and how it moves and turns, all around you. Get used to it. Australia [Read More...]

A high Australian dollar means we’re doing well at exporting. A low one means our trade balance is l [Read More...]

From the invasion of the Philippines to the Vietnam War…the US empire was financed by the rich, prod [Read More...]


"I think you're fantastic! I love to read what you write...you're so interesting and amusing and I've learned so much" -
Money Morning reader, Chris Gadd

"You guys are brilliant. I feel more relaxed about the future than ever simply because I know what is going on rather than floundering around with smoke screens and mirrors from the government and mainstream" -
Money Morning reader, Helen Carter

"Wow what can I say? I was an economically confused moron until I read your newsletter and even though I've been a subscriber for a short period I can now see how easy it is to understand, if you use common sense and can have the spin translated into everyday language. Thanks for an entertaining read." -
Money Morning reader, John

"Keep up the good independent and well thought out articles offering a view that often debunks mainstream myths." -
Money Morning reader, Craig

"I do admire your straight talking and simple analysis of the situation, I think of you as the Jeremy Clarkson of finance." -
Money Morning reader, Jeffery