- Money Morning Australia

The Price of Risk in the Stock Market

Written on 12 December 2012 by Murray Dawes


The disparity between the markets and reality on the ground continues to widen. The November NAB survey showed business confidence plummeted to minus 9 from minus 1 in October.

That takes business confidence to the weakest level since April 2009. In April 2009 the ASX 200 was trading near 3,600 or 22% below the level it’s trading at now.

I’m not saying that we should necessarily be trading at that level with business confidence so low but it’s interesting that we had just experienced a stock market crash back in early 2009. Fast forward to today and our stock market has been rallying for six months and is retesting multi-year highs.

Something doesn’t add up.

Either the stock market is getting ahead of itself or the pessimism in business is misplaced…

NAB said that ‘overall the survey implies a significant slowing in underlying demand and GDP growth in the December quarter, both easing to around 2 ¼ per cent – clearly below trend.’

A closer inspection of the ASX 200 shows that the rally isn’t very broad based. There is a large divergence opening up between different sectors of the economy.

Comparison of Australian Sector Indices

Comparison of Australian Sector Indices
Click here to enlarge

Source: Slipstream Trader

The financials make up a huge part of the ASX 200. The big four banks alone are nearly 25% of the index. So when they rally the index goes up.

Looking at the chart you can see that the financials are rallying strongly at the moment. But the small-cap stocks are not being taken along for the ride. The resources stocks have also underperformed since the start of the year, although they’ve picked up some steam over the last month.

Basically we’re seeing the outcome of the US Federal Reserve’s ZIRP (zero interest rate policy). Yields have been forced so low worldwide that anything with a yield is now being bought with ears pinned back.

Commonwealth Bank [ASX: CBA] is now yielding just under 5.5%. I wonder what yield it needs to get to before the market decides that the risk isn’t worth it? 5%? 4%?

If the market is happy to accept a 5% yield on CBA then the price could rally from its current price of $61.00 to around $67.00 based on the last year’s total dividend of $3.34.

So the rising stock market no longer reflects the prospects of the economy, but instead is a function of low interest rates. This begs the question, ‘Is it worth getting a 5% yield if you lose 50% of your capital?’

CBA fell from $62.00 to under $25.00 from 2007 to early 2009. As we approach that $62.00 level again I don’t think it is an outrageous question to ask.

Australian Interest Rates

Australian Interest Rates
Click here to enlarge

Also, if the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) is lowering interest rates due to deterioration in the underlying economy, is that really a signal to buy the stock market? The RBA slashed rates during 2008, and I’m sure you remember what stocks did then.

The level rates are at now is equivalent to where they were after the crash. So either the RBA is panicking or our stock market is oblivious to the risks facing us in the immediate future.

Macroeconomic data continues to deteriorate around the world. China’s trade surplus fell 38% over the last month from $32 billion to $19.6 billion, which is a huge fall. Europe is slowing and going into reverse, Japan is back in yet another recession. America is getting close to stall speed.

But interest rates are lower, so let’s buy the stock market! Yeah, right.

I know I’ve shouted my bearish view from the rooftops, and the fact that we closed yesterday at multi-year highs is making it harder to stick to that view, but it’s only a matter of time until the market tops out and starts heading down again.

The Santa rally appears to be alive and well. We have the FOMC meeting tomorrow night which will probably see the US Fed printing another US$45 billion a month to make up for the loss of Operation Twist.

If there is any good news in relation to the fiscal cliff drama we may indeed see a sharp spike higher in equity markets in the short term.

But unless the RBA plans on dropping rates again in the near term to fire the banks up further, I can’t see the ASX 200 trading that much higher from here.

And I don’t think that RBA governor Glenn Stevens has the stomach to continue dropping rates further in the very near term. A recent article in the Age by Clancy Yeates said that Governor Stevens thinks that, ‘Central banks should be prepared to take the heat out of asset price booms, rather than relying on lower interest rates to “clean up” the mess after bubbles burst.’

If he is prepared to lean on asset bubbles before they become a problem then I don’t think he’ll be that keen to create a bubble by dropping rates too low.

I found another comment by Governor Stevens quite illuminating. He said that:

‘I would have thought that by this point we have to conclude that simply expecting to clean up after the credit boom is not sufficient any more; the mess might be so large that monetary policy ends up not being able to do the job when the time comes.’

I think we all know that that time has already come and gone. ZIRP worldwide and endless money printing is the result.

Murray Dawes
Slipstream Trader

From the Port Phillip Publishing Library

Special Report: The Fuse is Lit

Daily Reckoning:
Why Free Speech is the Most Important of All the Civil Liberties

Money Morning:
Why Silver Could Be the Best Investment in 2013

Pursuit of Happiness:
Government: The Holy Hangman Still Kills

Australian Small-Cap Investigator:
Why Speculating On Small-Cap Stocks is Your Best Bet in a Rigged Market

Already a subscriber to Money Morning... or simply, just like what you're reading? Then show your support and spread the word...
Share this post on...

Leave a Comment

Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.

If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to moneymorning@moneymorning.com.au

Comments are closed.


"I think you're fantastic! I love to read what you write...you're so interesting and amusing and I've learned so much" -
Money Morning reader, Chris Gadd

"You guys are brilliant. I feel more relaxed about the future than ever simply because I know what is going on rather than floundering around with smoke screens and mirrors from the government and mainstream" -
Money Morning reader, Helen Carter

"Wow what can I say? I was an economically confused moron until I read your newsletter and even though I've been a subscriber for a short period I can now see how easy it is to understand, if you use common sense and can have the spin translated into everyday language. Thanks for an entertaining read." -
Money Morning reader, John

"Keep up the good independent and well thought out articles offering a view that often debunks mainstream myths." -
Money Morning reader, Craig

"I do admire your straight talking and simple analysis of the situation, I think of you as the Jeremy Clarkson of finance." -
Money Morning reader, Jeffery

FREE INVESTMENT REPORT: The Top 5 Oversold Blue-Chip Stocks in Australia

These five Aussie stocks all have something very powerful in common…and it could see them bounce up in the coming weeks and months. For all the details download this report right now.

PLUS you'll get Money Morning every weekday...absolutely free.

Enter your email address below and hit the 'Claim My Free Report' button now.

Privacy Statement
We will collect and handle your personal information in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
You can cancel your subscription at any time

Openx pos2

  • ^NDX4103.083-2.99 - -0.07%
  • ^FTSE6837.92+18.63 - +0.27%
  • ^AORD5437.300+18.300 - +0.34%
  • ^AXJO5433.100+17.300 - +0.32%
  • AUDUSD=X0.8927
  • USDJPY=X109.02

Openx pos3

Diggers and Drillers

After three years in the doldrums…

Aussie resource stocks
are now a raging BUY
The last time resource stocks traded this low we saw a two and a half year rally that saw them gain 124%...
Now they’re getting ready to do it again. Read on to discover why…and three tiny Aussie miners that could explode up many times higher than that in 2014…click here.

Openx pos4

Openx pos5

Openx pos6

Openx pos7

Openx pos8

More Recommended Reading Below...

The Pursuit of Happiness & The Daily Reckoning

  • The Pursuit of Happiness
  • The Daily Reckoning Australia

The NSA has set up a facility in Auckland to use the XKeyscore program to harvest all kinds of mass [Read More...]

The Aussie dollar has refused to bend to the government's will. While this week it fell a few c [Read More...]

The biggest fallout — from the industry’s point of view — is the instant depreciation to your car. A [Read More...]

By demanding bonds of long duration at such low rates, smart investors are signalling that they can [Read More...]

We currently live in a time in which technology creates huge opportunity for smart investors. More s [Read More...]

Chinese money is making its way into Australian Housing, regardless of the rules. All it takes is an [Read More...]

No time or place to catch up on the financial markets today. So we will tell you a bit of what went [Read More...]

Yes folks, the China property boom is well and truly over. It’s not a bust yet, but it’s fast shapin [Read More...]

All of a sudden - we had to think about investing! Then we found ourselves coming dangerously close [Read More...]

The RBA made special mention of the risks to the Australian economy of continued house price specula [Read More...]