In describing the dynamics of currency wars, I consistently use metaphors such as a tug of war or seesaw. This is to indicate that currency wars are never a one-way bet. Exchange rates go back and forth repeatedly.
The currency war that lasted 1921–1936 is a good example. In 1921, the Germans destroyed their currency in the famous Weimar Republic hyperinflation.
In 1925, France and Belgium devalued their currencies. That made British pounds sterling and the US dollar stronger.
In 1931, the UK struck back by devaluing pounds sterling. This put the pressure on France and the US.
Then, in 1933, the US. devalued the dollar, putting pressure back on the UK and even more pressure on France. Finally, in 1936, France and the UK. both devalued against the dollar again.
This was the infamous sequence of the ‘beggar thy neighbour’ devaluations.
Or consider the history of today’s currency war. We saw a weak Chinese yuan and strong dollar from 2008–2010.
Then in 2011, the US engineered a weak dollar. The Fed’s dollar index actually hit an all-time low in August 2011. At the same time, gold hit an all-time high — no coincidence there.
Next, the Japanese yen was cheapened under Abenomics beginning in December 2012.
By mid-2014, it was time to cheapen the euro, which crashed from $1.30 to $1.05 by January 2015. As a result, the dollar reached a 10-year high by mid-2015.
Then the Fed blinked and started to back away from rate increases, which took the dollar down a notch.
The point is there were no one-way bets. The US dollar got stronger from 1921–1933. Then it weakened from 1933–1936 and got stronger again after 1936. The dollar was also strong in 2010, weak in 2011 and strong again in 2015. The same analysis applies to the other major currencies.
That’s how currency wars play out.
The key to investing during currency wars is to focus on the underlying dynamics and stay nimble.
That’s exactly what we do.
We never put a permanent stake in the ground. We look for signals that tell us when the turning points are coming and adjust our recommendations accordingly.
Now looks like one of those times.
Most of the back-and-forth nature of exchange rates the past eight years is easily explained by central bank manipulations. Federal Reserve money printing during QE2 explains the weak dollar in 2011.
The Bank of Japan engaged in both quantitative ease and so-called ‘qualitative ease’ (using printed money to buy assets other than government bonds, such as stocks and corporate debt) to weaken the yen in 2013.
The European Central Bank used both negative interest rates and QE to weaken the euro in 2014.
The People’s Bank of China has used a mixed bag of interest rate cuts, bank reserve ratio reductions and direct intervention to weaken the yuan in 2015.
It’s always important to keep an eye on the central banks.
Yet, we are picking up signals from a source even more powerful than central banks. This source is the spectre of global recession.
It’s one thing for central banks to fight currency wars while the world is growing. That’s just a matter of stealing growth from your trading partners. When the pie is not growing fast enough, you can grab a bigger slice from the person sitting next to you with a cheap currency.
What happens when the whole pie is shrinking?
That’s what a recession is. In that environment, currency wars become much nastier and coordination breaks down.
The average US economic expansion since 1980 (a very favourable period for growth) lasted 77 months. As of now, the US economy has been expanding for 76 months, since the end of the last recession in June 2009. Admittedly, it has been a weak expansion, but it’s an expansion, nonetheless.
Does this mean the US economy goes into recession next month?
Not necessarily, but no one should be surprised if it does. Monthly job creation stalled out last November and has been shrinking ever since.
Disinflation and deflation have the upper hand on inflation. Many industrial production and purchasing manager indexes are flashing red. The Fed’s tough talk on interest rate increases hasn’t helped.
The picture in China is even bleaker. China is not technically in recession, because it’s starting from such a high growth rate. Yet even a slowdown in China has the same impact as a recession on the rest of the world, because of the lost output.
China is over 10% of global GDP. If Chinese growth shrinks by one-third (and that appears to be what’s happening), that takes 3.3% off of global GDP (10% x 33% = 3.3%). But global growth is only estimated to be 3.1% next year, according to the IMF.
If China slows down as much as we expect, that’s enough to wipe out global growth. That puts the entire world into a technical recession, even if some individual countries still have positive growth.
I have just returned from a visit to South Africa and the Middle East. I spent a lot of time with the top institutional investors and policymakers in both places. These are the areas getting caught in the crossfire of the currency wars.
The stories I heard are daunting. African commodity exports to China are collapsing. Middle Eastern dollar reserves are being depleted due to the collapse in oil prices and the resulting fiscal deficits.
What happens in China does not stay in China. It ripples around the world.
China is slowing and taking the world down with it
Excluding the financial crisis years of 2008–2009, Chinese growth is now at the lowest level in over 10 years. These are the official figures; most analysts estimate that actual growth is significantly lower than these figures show. China is over 10% of global GDP. If China slows by a third, that takes 3.3% off of global GDP.
That’s enough to put the entire world into a technical recession.
How will central banks stop the recession when they’ve used up their dry powder fighting the currency wars?
US interest rates are already zero. Japanese interest rates are zero also. European interest rates are negative. All of these central banks have printed trillions of dollars in their respective currencies under various QE programs. They are at the point where they simply cannot print trillions more without risking political backlash or the collapse of confidence in their currencies.
What this means is that the recession cannot be stopped. It will have to run its course over the next year or so.
All sectors of the economy will be affected, but some sectors will be hit worse than others. The service sector may hold up slightly better. Manufacturing and tradable goods tend to get hit the worst.
One of the signals we are picking up is the shrinkage in world trade. Investors tend to focus on trade deficits and surpluses, but those figures mask the fact that overall trade is shrinking.
You can have a reduced trade deficit but still find that exports and imports are both shrinking. The lower deficit sounds like good news, but the reduction of imports and exports is troubling. It means the global trading economy is shrinking: a sure sign of recession.
Strategist, Strategic Intelligence
From the Port Phillip Publishing Library
Special Report: If you want to get ahead in this world, it pays to have powerful friends in high places. With this new advisory, you’ll make one. A portfolio manager at the West Shore Group, and adviser on international economics and financial threats to the US Department of Defense. Jim Rickards is no ordinary financial newsletter writer. And Strategic Intelligence is no ordinary newsletter… (more)