Lynas Share Price Down as Malaysian Uncertainty Continues

By ,

At time of writing, the share price of Lynas Corporation Ltd [ASX:LYC] is down 2.13%, trading at $2.07 per share.

It has been a tough year for the Lynas share price, aside from a recent spike attributable to an acquisition proposal by Wesfarmers Ltd [ASX:WES]:

Lynas Share Price


In a busy news day for Lynas, it responded to comments by the Malaysian Prime Minister and it was revealed that it is considering the the possibility of moving its ‘cracking and leaching’ operations closer to its resource in Western Australia.

Interested in radioactive resources used to generate clean energy? Learn more about the uranium comeback in this free report. Hint: it’s all about what’s happening in Kazakhstan.

Lynas share price may be under pressure until Malaysian regulatory problems resolved

This is the key passage from the Malaysian Prime Minister’s press conference on Friday, as he is quoted by Lynas:

With regard to Lynas, we have imposed an extra condition, that is they must take away the waste. But they want to take away the waste to where? They want to take it to Australia, but Australia doesn’t want to accept it, so they can’t do it anyway.

So what we have done is we have opened up the business to other people, and there are other companies willing to buy up or somehow or other acquire Lynas, they have given us a promise that in future before sending the raw material to Malaysia they will clean it up first, they will crack it and decontaminate it in some way with regard to radioactivity, so that when the raw material comes here, the volume is less and the waste from that raw material is not dangerous to anybody.

‘So, they, this company or even Lynas they can continue if they promise that the raw material from Australia would be brought here only after, what they call, cracking and cleaning it up.

There is a surprising revelation here.

It is the suggestion by the Malaysian PM that they have been in discussion with ‘other companies’ about the processing plant.

Whether this is Wesfarmers or not, we will see.

Wesfarmers previously came in with a bid for Lynas and it would be somewhat cheeky of them to be in discussion with the Malaysian government about a processing plant they still do not own.

Governance called into question

Matthew Ryland, a portfolio manager with Greencape Capital (which is a substantial shareholder of Lynas) is quoted by The Sydney Morning Herald as saying:

We question the governance of companies that make undertakings to foreign governments about assets that they don’t own. We see that as a bit of a governance issue presenting itself.

Will Wesfarmers up the offer? Who knows?

Meanwhile, it has been reported that Lynas is seeking a way around the impasse with the Malaysian government by examining the value of operating ‘cracking and leaching’ operations near its Mt Weld mine.

Previously, we flagged a potential short-term pullback in the Lynas share price.

This may well continue, unless Wesfarmers ups the offer. So far there has been no specific mention of another suitor waiting in the wings.

I would caution against trying to bet on the news here. Unless you are an expert in the Malaysian regulatory environment. Even then, it seems as if there are simply too many variables.


Lachlann Tierney,
For Money Morning

PS: Find out why this ‘hated’ resource could rise from the dead in 2019 (free report).

About Lachlann Tierney

Lachlann Tierney is an Analyst for Money Morning and has been investing for nearly a decade. With a Masters of Science from the London School of Economics, he brings a sound understanding of global markets to his writing. Lachlann is interested in emerging technologies, energy solutions and helping people invest…

A Wall of Worry and Other ASX Truths — ASX-listed Gold Stocks

The first leg for gold stocks could be down to a value pivot or correction where existing profits and high-cash balances — there’s some great margins available…

Has Lynas’ Record Result Put Rare Earths Back on the Agenda?

In today’s Money Morning…the best may be yet to come…Europe follows the US’s lead to secure vital materials…the good news for Aussie rare earth miners…and more…

Lynas Share Price Down Marginally — Rare Earths Back on Menu

At time of writing, the share price of Lynas Rare Earths Ltd (ASX:LYC) is down around 0.8%, trading at $4.94. It’s been a strong and sustained surge for the LYC share price from the March low. We take a quick look at the LYC quarterly…

Lynas Share Price up on US Contract — Rare Earths Outlook (ASX:LYC)

At time of writing, the share price of Lynas Rare Earths Ltd [ASX:LYC] is up over 4%, trading at $4.89. It’s been a case of steady, and now accelerating, upward momentum for the LYC share price since the market low last year…

Lynas Share Price Down on Malaysia Processing Plant Update (ASX:LYC)

The share price of Lynas Corporation Ltd [ASX:LYC] is down 2.44%, trading at $2.40. You can see how the Lynas share price bounced strongly off the March market lows. Today, the company updated investors on its proposed Malaysian processing plant…

Lynas Share Price Up on US Facility Go Ahead: Two Factors to Consider

At time of writing, the share price of Lynas Corporation Ltd [ASX:LYC] is up more than 10%, trading at $2.39. Today, the company announced it has signed a deal with US DOD for Phase I of its US processing facility…